“I’m not sure I’m a Christian.”
You wouldn’t believe the amount of times I said or thought that during my teen years and even into my early twenties. It was doubt that constantly gnawed at my mind, threatening to consume and push me into the brink of despair. Okay, maybe that’s being a bit dramatic, but it certainly felt that way at times. Some days I allowed myself to believe the promises of the gospel were true, other times, a lot of times, I tended to believe that I couldn’t be a true child of God. I didn’t feel like it and my life didn’t appear to be radically different in comparison to other born-again believers who seemed to have this undying zeal to follow Christ. Sometimes it was almost like there was a competition to who had the greatest conversion story. So… what if you didn’t have one? How could I even consider myself to be a child of God when I didn’t appear to have a fraction of the zeal everyone spoke about? And why would an infinitely holy Creator care for an insignificant someone like me, anyway? Despite having all the head knowledge that Jesus Christ didn’t come save the extraordinary but that he came to save a hopeless, lost sinner that was in need for a serious life-changing heart work, it really did not click that the gospel was really meant for me, not for a long time.
Growing up in a Christian home, I attended church regularly. Several, actually, since we moved a lot. They ranged from brethren, reformed, and a few baptist churches. Church was something my family just did. My parents were both strong believers, coming out of non-Christian backgrounds, and were dedicated to the church and teaching me and my brothers the gospel. Unfortunately, though I attended various Sunday school classes, listened to many sermons, went to an Awana club, and youth groups, I never spoke about my growing fears. Besides my parents, most people assumed I was a ‘good Christian girl’ because I had professed to be a believer when I was ten, and later again when I was fourteen, and basically followed the rules and wasn’t a rebellious kid. Somewhere in midst of these professions, I usually ended up mournfully telling my mom that I didn’t actually know I was saved or not. When she tried to counsel me and explain the gospel again, I didn’t understand. To me it seemed everyone had these miraculous conversion stories, even my mom had a story, and everyone said you would know for sure that you were God’s child. But I didn’t. So I thought maybe my dramatic conversion hadn’t happened yet, and began to wonder if it ever would happen. Maybe God decided to exclude me. I desperately wanted to speak about the gospel and salvation, but I ended up closing myself up because I was tired of being a disappointment to my parents and it scared the living daylights out of me of telling my friends or youth leaders that I wasn’t a Christian when they all assumed I was, and if they didn’t assume I was, they never really bothered to take the time to figure out what my struggles were.
Why did I fear telling them that I wasn’t saved?
Perhaps it was because I feared that I didn’t live up to their expectations, or it would make friendships awkward, or perhaps what scared me the most was that they would all start preaching the gospel at me with that stern reality that I was going to hell if I didn’t say this prayer. They would tell me to just “repent” without really understanding that I was trying to believe God, that I had “repented” over a dozen times in the past, that I had flooded my pillow at night with tears because I was terrified of hell and cried to God, but I didn’t feel any change. How many more times did they want me to repent and believe? I didn’t want to fake Christianity, but how could I tell my friends that I had said a prayer to Jesus, but then simply…didn’t know. I had been told before to “just stop doubting”. But how could I just stop when those doubts felt so deeply rooted within? When they came with paralyzing fears that prayer couldn’t even seem to shake? If God really heard me, he’d take away the unwanted emotions that I toiled with and give me assurance, right? If I knew him as my Father, my faith should never waver. Therefore, I concluded, if I consistently struggled, then I couldn’t be a Christian. No other believer I knew fought like this. I had prayed countless times that God would take away the doubts, and he hadn’t, so he couldn’t possibly love me…Right?
Wrong.
I’m guessing that answer didn’t surprise you. So if it’s such an easy, predictable answer, why did it take me a good portion of my youth to actually believe it? There were a couple of things, maybe you won’t agree with, but when I finally realized there were some distorted perceptions in my thinking, I knew there were some serious changes that needed take place, and it’s changed me for the better.
My first mistake was that I constantly looked inward at myself, my failures, my feelings, rather than Christ. Sometimes I still unconsciously fall back into this old mindset, but it’s an area I am now aware that needs to be corrected and actively fight against it. During my times of doubting, however, there were plenty of of days I didn’t feel like reading the Bible, didn’t feel like praying, didn’t feel like going to church, or sitting under the preaching. So if I didn’t feel close to God, I thought it meant God didn’t love me. It’s not to say emotions are totally something we should be ignoring when it comes to gauging how our relationship with God is, for it is serious to not desire spiritual things or wanting to be with God, and that in itself is something that needs to be addressed. This is why it is good to sometimes go through a passage like 1 John to determine whether you are truly in the faith and reflect on where you are in your spiritual walk, but being in a perpetual state of doubt and self-examination is unhealthy and in no way how God wants you to live your life.
There are times one simply cannot rely upon emotions when figuring out whether you are a child of God because it will leave you completely and utterly at loss. The heart is not always accurate. It is often deceptive. Come again? Shouldn’t we feel that it’s right to follow our dreams and desires? If you go by the world’s standards, yes, you should follow everything your heart says, along with all its selfish and corrupt wants, even at the expense of hurting others. Yet as believers in Christ we are not to follow the world. So if we know that we are fallen by human nature, tainted by sin, then we need to be aware that what we feel and think is right can very often be contrary to the truth of God’s Word.
In that sense, my feelings were very contrary to God’s Word. Instead of believing the gospel, even after reading well-known verses such as John 3:16 that, “For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son that whoever believes in him will not perish will have eternal life.” I questioned whether it really was for me, whether God actually died for me, even if he said he did. I rather was fixated upon myself. I did not cling to the truths of the Bible, but allowed myself to be wallow in a pit of lies instead. Again, it’s not to say emotions aren’t real or important. They are. But sometimes we just have to get up and say no to them when they are leading us in the wrong direction. You need to align your heart and mind with God first before trusting in what you feel. When it comes to salvation, the Scripture tells us, “because, if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved.” (Romans 10:9-10). God didn’t say, well, if you don’t feel like my child today, you’re out of the kingdom, so long loser. He wouldn’t just send his Son to die for you just so he can cast you out the moment you mess up. So whether you feel like it or not, you need to anchor yourself in Christ and focus upon him, not self.
The second reason I doubted for so long was due to the fact that I did not view my unbelief and doubting as a sin. Wait. Did you just say sin? How can you blame me for feeling these dark emotions of self-hate? How can you blame me for trying to believe when I can’t believe? God’s the one who is supposed to change my heart in the first place, and it’s not like I’ve prayed a thousand times for him to take away my doubts.
So…does that mean we’re blaming a holy, merciful, loving God who sent his only Son to die for lost souls like you and me, a God who hates sin, a God made it possible for us to have a relationship with him, that he’s cause of our doubting…? Are we saying that God would rather that we stay in darkness than grow closer to him? Matthew 11: 25-30 says: “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn from me, for I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light.” God is not so cruel that he would call us to himself that just leave us to fend for ourselves alone. He promises in his Word to give us rest. Unlike us, God doesn’t lie. He’s true to his word. He is our Father, a perfect Father, who cares very deeply for each and every one of his children.
But you don’t understand, how do I know I’m his child?
You spend time with God. Not just this hurried, half-hearted five minute a day devotional. Not just this quick-whispered prayer that you didn’t really mean at all. Not just a passing glance at a couple verses. You come to him confessing your weaknesses. You dig deeper into the Word of God, focusing on the attributes of his character. You dwell upon the truth revealed in his Word and ask for him to help you understand those truths, and you ask him to help you have a desire for his truths… and not just once or twice, keep asking! You admit to God when you don’t feel like doing spiritual things, when you have moments of failure, and you pursue God even when you don’t feel like it, especially when you don’t feel like it. God’s not going to reject you when you are seeking him. He’s not going to abandon you.
If it weren’t for God upholding me, I would have left the faith. Several times during my off and on seasons of doubting, I wanted to give up. I remember even saying along the lines, “God, I can’t go on like this. I’m done with this whole seeking thing.” Or even the year I started college, ashamedly writing to myself that, “God doesn’t matter anymore.” Instead I decided I would focus on just making myself a career, give myself over to the busyness of school, and deliberately trying to forget the battles I faced. If God would have let me, I would have drifted and immersed myself into the world and left the Christian faith altogether. But he didn’t let me go. God, either through a friend, my parents, a sermon, or some testimony, always drew me back, reminding me of his presence, reminding me that he was there. It was like I couldn’t shut him off, even if I tried to.
God is not going to let you go, but he doesn’t expect you just to sit on your hands and do nothing. You’re not magically going to fix your broken, messed up heart by ignoring God and dwelling upon yourself. You can’t fix your own heart. You need God to do this. This is why I say to keep praying and digging in his Word. Keep searching till you find the answer. Then take a firm hold onto the answer in the truth of God’s Word that is provided to you. It is only by looking to Christ that you can gain assurance and not by your own merit, and it is is only through Christ that we come to find rest and truly know Him.